Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Why is George Bush Wading Into Denver's Education Debate on the Eve of Critical School Board Elections?

Ohanian Comment: It's discouraging that Emily Sirota sticka to the party line regarding Colorado Senator Michael Bennet. Seems like it might be enough to point out that in 2009 he was Democrats for Education Reform Reformer of the Month. Nichols doesn't notice because he's too busy bashing the easy target.

Reader Comment:
Mr. Nichols,

You might have mentioned that Mayor Hancock is a Democrat and that he is not alone among Democrats in supporting charter schools, school choice and privatization, including President Obama, his Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, and Duncan's old boss, former Mayor of Chicago Richard M. Daley. And you might have criticized all of them for doing so, and Obama and Duncan for giving us more of the same standardized test-based crap in their "Race to the Top."

I have on occasion defended you against some of the right-wing posters here, but you don't make it easy when you shill for the Democrats by ignoring the fact that much of their leadership is supporting the private-sector's efforts to take over public education.

by John Nichols

Former President George W. Bush, whose administration once made a big deal about its diplomatic engagement with Libyan dictator Muammar Qaddafi, won't talk about the recent unfortunate turn of events for the strongman. And don't try to get Bush started on any of those pesky questions about jobs and the economy that his administration ran into the ground. He's not talking.

But if you want to talk about how the schools in Denver, Colorado, should be run, Bush's has got plenty to say.

"I'm out of politicsâ€Â¦but I still have a great passion about educational excellence," Bush announced when he showed up in Denver last Thursday.

But the scheduling of Bush's visit to the city's "Get Smart Schools" program couldn't have been more political. Indeed, advocates for public education in what has become the most intense school board election in the country are bluntly suggesting that Bush’s visit was "politically timed."

Appearing in Colorado's largest city barely ten days before the most hotly contested school board elections in the the community's history, Bush talked up an education agenda being advanced by so-called school “reformers,” who have been backed by wealthy oil barons and national conservative groups that want to see Denver experiment with school charter, school choice and privatization schemes. And he did so with Denver Mayor Michael Hancock at his side.

Hancock has waded into the Denver School Board competition, endorsing candidates favored by the out-of-town special interests, and suggesting that if things didn't go they way he may reverse his previous position and press for mayoral control of Denver schools.

Emily Sirota, a Denver school board candidate who has campaigned on behalf of maintaining strong public schools--and assuring that those schools are run by elected representatives of the people, rather than outside interests or powerful politicians--has been countering Hancock. "I agree with Mayor Hancock that the current school board is overly divisive and dysfunctional. In fact, that's exactly why I'm running for school board--to finally put an end to the bickering and refocus our schools on the needs of our kids," says Sirota. "However, the mayor only added to the current divisiveness and dysfunction when he needlessly inserted himself into the school board election. Additionally, he's now making matters even worse with his suggestion that he may be open to trying to disband the elected school board unless his handpicked slate of candidates is successful in buying the upcoming election. Voters aren’t interested in that kind of extortion. That's not a way to forge consensus and refocus DPS on the needs of our kids, which should be our top priority."

When Bush showed up and appeared with the mayor, Sirota pushed back even harder, suggesting that the mayor was wrong for "praising the No Child Left Behind Act during President George W. Bush's politically timed visit to Denver today."

"Mayor Hancock has rightly decried divisiveness and dysfunction in our education system--but standing with George W. Bush during an election-timed visit is not the way to start fixing that problem, nor are his comments today promoting the failed No Child Left Behind policy that has so harmed our schools," said Sirota. "No Child Left Behind is one of the most destructive education policies enacted in the last 10 years. Our mayo'’s behavior today only draws unnecessary lines in the sand, while needlessly undermining the important work of Senator Bennet, who is working to finally reform No Child Left Behind. If there's any good news out of President Bush's visit to Denver, it is that Superintendent [Tom] Boasberg, unlike our Mayor, had the guts to speak out against No Child Left Behind. His statements suggest that he recognizes that we need to couple accountability with a reinvestment in our schools."

The November 1 Denver School Board election has already attracted more than $600,000 in campaign donations, with much of the money coming in the form of $10,000 and $25,000 checks to candidates backed by groups that favor the school choice, charter school and privatization schemes. Sirota is running one of three races in the city. She's being massively outspent, yet is generally seen as running a competitive race.

If Sirota wins, the likelihood is that control of the School Board will flip from the so-called "reformers" to a pro–public education majority.

Why all the attention to the Denver race? In fact, special-interest groups are pouring money into school board an state board of education races across the country this year. But the Denver race is critical, as it could shift the direction of one of the nation's largest urban school districts and send powerful signals regarding the direction of public education nationally.

(John Nichols and Robert McChesney, co-founders of the media reform group Free Press, wrote the groundbreaking examination of the collision of big money and bad media, "The Money & Media Election Complex," for The Nation. Their examination of the damage done to democracy by the billionaire-dollar campaigns and the decline of journalism, Dollarocracy, will be published next year by Nation Books.)

— John Nichols blog
The Nation





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.