Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

In Defense Of The Mic Check

Ohanian Note: I try to avoid Huffington Post, but when Steve Krashen Tweeted this, I decided I should look. It puts the Chicago Mic Check in a very understandable--and important--context for those of us not in Chicago. We already had a full coverage of Chicago Mic Check from Substance, but democracy in action bears repeating. With that in mind, this item could be posted in Good News.

John Kugler Comment:

"MIC CHECK!! "Parents, teachers, students and communities
reject CPS failed reforms. We now know that only 18 percent of
the replacement schools perform well. Most of those are
selected enrollment schools run by CPS. Nearly 40% of the new
schools are performance level 3, CPS' lowest rating. We see
through the sound-bites. You have betrayed the public
trust. You have failed Chicago's children. You pray at the
altar of greed And dare call it education. We value people
over profit. Every life is precious. Our children are not
product. But look at what you've produced Children have
died Literally and spiritually As a result of your
policies You have produced chaos. Mayor Emmanuel you should
be ashamed. Brizard, you should be ashamed. You should both
be fired. Stanford University says you have failed. The
University of Chicago says you have failed. The Chicago
Tribune says you have failed. Most importantly, the people
know you have failed. The definition of insanity is to
repeatedly do the same thing and expect a different
result. These are our children, not yours. These are our
children, not yours. We are taking our fight to the mayor! We
are taking our fight to the courts! We are taking our fight to
the schools! We are taking our fight to the streets! These
are our children, not corporate product. These are our
children, not corporate product. These are our children, not
corporate product!""

by Kenzo Shibata
Editor, Chicago Union Teacher

After years of attending Chicago Board of Education monthly meetings, on December 14, 2011 I felt like I left one where the community was actually heard, by the public and by the board. During the "public participation" segment of the meeting, a lone voice stopped the business-as-usual.

From the Chicago Sun-Times:

Adourthus McDowell, a Chicago Public School parent and member of the Kenwood-Oakland Community Organization, began the takeover by rising from his chair and interrupting a presentation by Chicago Schools CEO Jean-Claude Brizard on a new $660 million capital construction plan.â¨â¨

Using a 'mic check' technique borrowed from Occupy Wall Street protestors, McDowell read from a prepared text in short bursts so comrades planted around the room could repeat his words and thereby amplify them for the crowd.

The action continued. Parents, educators, and community activists repeated Mr. McDowell's speech and were escorted out of the room one-by-one.

Some local bloggers and politicians have become highly critical of the "mic check" tactic, where public meetings and events are upstaged by the voice of those who feel voiceless. On its face, it does appear to be rude and counterproductive.

â¨â¨This would be true if these public meetings really were about providing community input. I've attended hundreds of public meetings, both as an activist and as a reporter. Board of Education "public participation" segments are two hours where taxpayers are allowed two minutes each to describe decades of neglect or outright sabotage of their school communities, as bemused members of the Board of Education play on their Blackberries.

Ever have that nightmare where something terrible is happening and you can't scream for help? For the parents, students, and educators who take a day off of work to attend these meetings, this becomes a reality.

This particular meeting was held in the wake of CPS' announcement to close and turnaround more schools. Many came to defend their school communities. They were prepared with data and research to show why the board should halt their plans.

From the Chicagoist:

A study by UIC professors last year showed that the turnaround model espoused initially by CPS during the Richard M. Daley administration has served largely to re-segregate the school system.

The Board of Education didn't get to hear any of this at the meeting, as James Warren describes in the New York Times:

David Vitale retreated into executive session. Mr. Vitale is a banker who was picked by Rahm Emanuel to be president of the Chicago Board of Education.

This was after the Mr. Vitale, much like a bad first-year teacher:

... told the crowd that he hoped they'd 'gotten it out of their system,' prompting more jeers.

â¨â¨'We need you out of our system,' one man yelled back.

It seems that when confronted by the public they chose to serve, the Board of Education retreats. After the board members left the room, Jesse Sharkey -- the vice president of the Chicago Teachers Union -- who taught for over a decade in CPS schools explained their cowardice:

'I've had many hard days as a teacher and... you can't just take your ball and go home,' Sharkey said, addressing the empty seats.

When you are working on changing a system led by the richest people in the city who have no patience for the people whose taxes pay their stipends and subsidize their friends, you have to come up with new tactics.

Had the community members played by the board's rules last week, the meeting would have been just another one like countless others. Motions would be passed and communities would be destroyed, as members of the board could continue playing Words With Friends.

— Kenzo Shibata with John Kugler Comment
Huffington Post





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.