Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Preschoolers in Surgery for a Mouthful of Cavities

Not surprisingly, this front-page article provoked LOTS of comments. Here are a few.

Reader Comment [receiving the most 'thumbs up']: As a dentist with almost 30 years clinical experience, these situations have always made me nuts. let's put it bluntly- the parents are 100% to blame. I've never seen a 3 year old walk to the store and buy a soda himself. This level of poor parenting is tantamount to child abuse. there is just no way around it. it's so much easier to shut an agitated child up by shoving sugar into her mouth than trying to deal with it. my niece's husband actually told me that he was giving his infant sugar because "he likes it." wow. thank you for giving this important issue front page coverage!

Reader Comment [receiving only one less 'thumbs up']: It's the teachers' fault. If they weren't in unions and if they got evaluated with standardized tests every year, all these problems would disappear. It couldn't possibly have anything to do with the parents.

It's the dentists' fault. etc

Wash rinse repeat.

Reader Comment: I have to wonder what other things are being neglected both physically and emotionally that won't show up for years. Raising a child takes so much time -- something that is in short supply among most of us. They needed to be wanted and planned for, and none of us has any idea just how much parenthood requires of us until we're into it. Don't even get me started on the need for good contraception. Sincere best wishes to all the parents out there who are overwhelmed. We --myself included -- should try to be less judgmental and more supportive.

Reader Comment: So Melody Koester, an unemployed housewife, admits "she had other things on her mind" that apparently prevented her from brushing her son's teeth that would have taken all of 1 minute every evening. Typical dingbat.

Reader Comment: Of course, we could take steps as a society to limit the marketing and advertising of junk food--especially to young children. Many of today̢۪s younger parents were themselves brought up in this environment of tv/ads/junk food on every corner--it seems totally natural to them by now.

By Catherine Saint Louis

SEATTLE — In the surgical wing of the Center for Pediatric Dentistry at Seattle Children’s Hospital, Devon Koester, 2 ½ years old, was resting last month in his mother’s arms as an anesthesiologist held a bubble-gum-scented mask over his face to put him under. The doctors then took X-rays, which showed that 11 of his 20 baby teeth had cavities. Then his pediatric dentist extracted two incisors, performed a root canal on a molar, and gave the rest fillings and crowns.

Devon̢۪s mother, Melody Koester, a homemaker from Stanwood, Wash., and her husband, Matthew, an information technology manager, said they began worrying about brushing Devon's teeth only after Mrs. Koester noticed they were discolored when he was 18 months old. "I had a lot on my mind, and brushing his teeth was an extra thing I didn't think about at night," she said.

The number of preschoolers requiring extensive dental work suggests that many other parents make the same mistake. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention noted an increase, the first in 40 years, in the number of preschoolers with cavities in a study five years ago. But dentists nationwide say they are seeing more preschoolers at all income levels with 6 to 10 cavities or more. The level of decay, they added, is so severe that they often recommend using general anesthesia because young children are unlikely to sit through such extensive procedures while they are awake.

There is no central clearinghouse for data on the number of young children undergoing general anesthesia to treat multiple cavities, but interviews with 20 dentists and others in the field of dental surgery suggest that the problem is widespread.

"We have had a huge increase in kids going to the operating room," said Dr. Jonathan Shenkin, a pediatric dentist in Augusta, Me., and a spokesman for the American Dental Association. "We're treating more kids more aggressively earlier."

But such operations are largely preventable, he said. "I have parents tell me all the time, 'No one told us when to go to the dentist, when we should start using fluoride toothpaste' -- all this basic information to combat the No. 1 chronic disease in children."

Dentists offer a number of reasons so many preschoolers suffer from such extensive dental decay. Though they are not necessarily new, they have combined to create a growing problem: endless snacking and juice or other sweet drinks at bedtime, parents who choose bottled water rather than fluoridated tap water for their children, and a lack of awareness that infants should, according to pediatric experts, visit a dentist by age 1 to be assessed for future cavity risk, even though they may have only a few teeth.

And because some toddlers dislike tooth-brushing, some parents do not enforce it. "Let's say a child is 1 ½, and the child screams when they get their teeth cleaned," said Dr. Jed Best, a pediatric dentist in Manhattan. "Some parents say, 'I don't want my little darling to be traumatized.' The metaphor I give them is, 'I'd much rather have a kid cry with a soft toothbrush than when I have to drill a cavity.'"

Dental decay often starts with a dull ache that may be mistaken for teething. That is why parents do not realize their child's teeth are infected until they break or the pain becomes so acute that the child cannot sleep, said Dr. Joel Berg, director of the Center for Pediatric Dentistry, a joint venture since 2010 between the University of Washington and Seattle Children̢۪s Hospital, which built a surgical wing because of the demand for oral surgery for preschoolers.

With a cooperative child, a cavity -- or even many --can be treated in a dentist's office with an injection of local anesthesia and an episode of "The Backyardigans' to distract patients.

But dentists routinely recommend general anesthesia for preschoolers with extensive problems, particularly if they will not even let X-rays be taken. The cost to parents for dental restoration under general anesthesia for a child ranges from $2,000 to $5,000 or more, depending on insurance coverage and the amount of work, several dentists said.

Dr. Megann Smiley, a dentist-anesthesiologist at Nationwide Children's Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, is used to hearing parents question the need for general anesthesia to fix their children's infected teeth. "It seems like putting a match out with a fire hydrant," Dr. Smiley said. "But if any of us tried to get 12 teeth treated, we wouldn't think that's small."

The dental surgery center at Nationwide has three operating rooms, which staff members and local dentists used to treat roughly 2,525 children in 2011, 6 percent more than in 2010. The average age of patients is 4, and most have decay in six to eight teeth, she said.

"The most severe cases have 12 or 16, which is seen several times a week," Dr. Smiley added.

Using general anesthesia on healthy children has risks, including vomiting and nausea, and, in very rare cases, brain damage or death. Using anti-anxiety drugs to relax a child coupled with local anesthesia for pain has risks, too, including an overdose that could suppress breathing.

Hannah Schwartz of Brooklyn refused general anesthesia for her 3 ½-year-old daughter, Alice. By then, one of Alice's eight cavities had already been treated in a dentist's office using a papoose board to immobilize her from head to ankle with straps. Her daughter screamed, "Take it off me!" for the 20-minute procedure, said Ms. Schwartz, a nursing student.

Afterward, "I left the room and burst into tears without Alice seeing," she said, adding that she would try a third option, laughing gas.

Of course, the lack of money or insurance can be an issue, but several dentists in interviews nationwide attributed extensive cavities in part to lax parenting, at all income levels.

"It's not just about kids in poverty, though kids of lower socioeconomic status tend to get more cavities," said Dr. Rochelle Lindemeyer, director of the pediatric dentistry residency program at Children̢۪s Hospital of Philadelphia and the University of Pennsylvania dental school. Affluent families may have nannies who "pacify kids by giving them a sippy cup all day," Dr. Lindemeyer said.

Brushing teeth twice a day used to be nonnegotiable, she said, but not anymore. "Some parents say: 'He doesn't want his teeth brushed. We'll wait until he's more emotionally mature.' It's baffling," she added.

Dr. Man Wai Ng , the dentist in chief at Children's Hospital Boston, said she heard parents, rich and poor, make similar rationalizations about their preschoolers' snacking, like, "I can't ever imagine Johnny being hungry, so I'm laying out a whole-wheat spread that's always available."

With a grant from the DentaQuest Institute, Dr. Ng started a disease-management program to alter the habits of parents of children with cavities so some could avoid the operating room. Her advice includes less frequent snacks, and only four ounces of juice a day. She does not forbid sweets, but suggests brushing afterward, and bacteria-killing Xylitol lollipops.

Multiple studies have shown that even children who undergo general anesthesia to treat dental decay end up with cavities again. Janine Costantini, the ambulatory practice director at Children̢۪s Hospital Colorado, said the staff treated a 3-year-old who was making his second visit to the operating room for dental work. The boy arrived with a bottle of Coca-Cola.

— Catherine Saint Louis
New York Times





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.