Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

US Public School System is Under Attack In Philadelphia, the privatisation of the public school system isn't working -- yet the stage is set for even more.

Reader Comment: As with the corporate media and corporate-controlled government, the longterm plan is to "profitize" our public schools to completely remove any last vestiges of critical thinking from our populace, starting with our children, to guarantee the future world order of unquestioning worker/slaves who will be satisfied with low-wage, dead-end jobs, lousy but unaffordable health care, and be forced, out of financial necessity, to enlist in our "volunteer" mercenary forces to continue to expand the Empire abroad as the nation continues to deteriorate at home.

This is the future planned for the 99%, starting with our schools being hollowed out from within.

Reader Comment: This article is right on. When are news media going to begin to call it what it is? It is simply another scheme to segregate public schools. It is a way to keep People of color poorly educated and dependent on whatever the system will let them have.

Reader Comment: regardless of the ethnicity of the collateral damage (students, teachers, other school personnel,) the "scheme" is to hamstring and eviscerate, then depreciate and discredit, then infiltrate, incorporate and exsanguinate public educationâ€Â¦ and all of the public sectorâ€Â¦ it's happening all over, including here in the Big Apple. Philly (like New Orleans) seems to be further down the road to perdition, but Mayor Mike is certainly doing his level best to play catch-up. NCLB, and its evil step-child "Race to the Top" are facilitating this seemingly-inexorable downward spiral by creating a tyranny of ultimately-unattainable metrics and inducing final-solution balkanizations of schools that were, from the outset, never, ever given a fighting chance to succeed.

by Liza Featherstone

The US public school system, once a model for the world, is under sustained attack by the nation's elites. Philadelphia, the latest casualty, is getting ready to sell off its schools -- and their governance -- to profiteers and snake-oil salesmen. We already know how this story ends.

The Philadelphia school system announced in late April that it was on the brink of insolvency and would be turned over to private operators, dissolving most remnants of democratic governance. Specifically, if the city's leaders have their way, 64 of the city's neighbourhood public schools will close over the next five years, and by 2017, 40 per cent of the city's children will attend charter schools. These are privately run schools that use public funds. Perhaps most disturbingly to those who value democracy and doubt the wisdom of corporate elites, the city will have no oversight of its own school system. Schools will instead be governed by "networks", control of which will be auctioned off through a bidding process, and could be bestowed on anyone - including a CEO of a for-profit education company.

The situation in Philadelphia, which has received amazingly little attention from the national media in the US, offers a disturbing window onto what the US elite is planning for the rest of our public schools - disturbing because Philadelphia's experience has already demonstrated that turning public education over to private entities will ultimately lead to its destruction.

The fact is Philadelphia is already the most privatized system in the US. In 2001, the state of Pennsylvania took over the city's school system and turned many of its schools over to private operators, even offering up 25 schools to for-profit companies. A study [PDF] by Vaughan Byrnes of Johns Hopkins University showed that, five years into this sweeping overhaul, the schools under private management were academically underperforming the public schools.

Not surprisingly, the bad education delivered by privatized education also comes with a heavy dose of corruption: at least six Philadelphia charter schools are under criminal investigation by the office of the state's attorney general, after the Philadelphia Inquirer - and the city's comptroller - reported rampant financial mismanagement and nepotism in the city's charter system. As in other cities, public money was extensively abused in real estate profiteering schemes, as charter school operators used schools as tenants, paying money to themselves to rent their own property. In one particularly classy instance, the charter operator was running a private parking lot on school property. Exorbitant salaries were common for the charter school operators, and some implausibly held fully salaried jobs in multiple schools, billing the city for more than 365 days in a year. At least two Philadelphia charter school operators have pleaded guilty to one such series of frauds - with sentencing scheduled for July - and the Inquirer's investigations may lead to further prosecutions.

In US public schools, privatization and austerity are presented as solutions to problems largely caused by - wait for it - privatisation and austerity. But these are not solutions at all - just a recipe for more of the same.

Austerity has been a crucial partner for privatizers in the United States, where New Orleans has endured an overhaul similar to Philadelphia's, and school systems in New York and Chicago are suffering a more gradual erosion. Schools are starved of resources. Then the rich and their for-profit companies are brought in as white knights to "save" - or loot, whichever they prefer - the failing systems. In Philadelphia, according to the alternative City Paper, "it has been a long time since the schools had close to adequate funding". Indeed, for years, the state of Pennsylvania fought a lawsuit, filed in 1999, by the city of Philadelphia, its school district and the National Association of Colored People (NAACP), charging the state with racial discrimination: the city's schools, attended largely by poor children of colour, had been systematically under-funded, compared with suburban and rural districts, which are predominantly white.

To be sure, many of Philadelphia's public schools are no place for children, and there is plenty of room for real reform. Unlike in New York City, most middle-class people in Philadelphia don't choose to send their children to inner-city public schools, instead making great financial sacrifices to move to the suburbs. But only in the mad libertarian climate of current US politics could any sensible person believe that the destruction of the city's schools will cure their woes.

In US public schools, privatization and austerity are presented as solutions to problems largely caused by - wait for it - privatisation and austerity. But these are not solutions at all - just a recipe for more of the same.

Liza Featherstone is a contributing editor for The Nation and a journalist based in New York City. She is the co-author of Students Against Sweatshops: The Making of a Movement (Verso, 2002) and author of Selling Women Short: The Landmark Battle for Worker's Rights at Wal-Mart (Basic, 2004).

— Liza Feathersone
Al-Jazeera and Common Dreams





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.