Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Let them eat tests

NOTE: This blog by a Texas political consultant is syndicated by Cagle Cartoons and had this cartoon as illustration.

You can read Sandy Kress' response here. Jason Stanford proposes giving him a reading comprehension test. Then Kress responded to the response. Clearly, he thinks he's above criticism. Or judgment.

by Jason Stanford

We celebrate report cards in my family by letting the boys pick a dinner menu. My oldest always picks steak. My youngest likes beige food—pasta, mac & cheese, and potatoes. When he finished the 3rd grade this year, he chose KFC (beige again) for getting all A’s except for two B’s. I asked him what he learned this year, and he mentioned a lesson about the double helix and that squids have three hearts.

Then he said this: “I learned strategies. How to focus andâ€Â¦ I forget the other one. Oh yeah, practicing doing tests.” He’s talking about the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness (STAARâ„¢) that Texas began administering this year in the hopes that testing our children will make them smarter. Texas is paying Pearson Education $470 million over five years for STAAR test, but since Texas also cut $5.4 billion from the public school budget, the state decided the tests shouldn’t actually count towards anything.

Meanwhile, Sandy Kress sends his children to private schools in Austin where, like at 90% of Texas private schools, they don’t take the state’s standardized tests. Where the Kress children go to school doesn’t matter except that he was the “key architect” of “No Child Left Behind” and now is the lead lobbyist for Pearson.

While Kress’ kids get a first-class secondary education, his tests have incited an open revolt over the test-first, test-later culture. So far, 520 Texas school boards representing millions of schoolchildren have passed a resolution opposing over-testing. Even the Lufkin Chamber of Commerce has joined the revolution against the let-them-eat-tests oligarchy. Now the Texas protest has gone viral. A national resolution has thousands of signatories, and parents are protesting at Pearson's headquarters in New York.

Newt Gingrich won back Congress with his Contract With America by fighting this kind of out-of-touch elitism. The Contract's first principle was that "all laws that apply to the rest of the country also apply equally to the Congress." Nothing came of it, but this bullet point hit the bull's eye with focus groups because of the House banking scandal, Speaker Jim Wright's book sales to lobbyists, and Rep. Dan Rostenkowski's corruption charges. There was the sense that Congress had "gone Washington" and was not living by the same rules the rest of us did.

Some of that unfairness applies here. Americans rightfully loathe living by rules that don't apply to those who make the rules. We hate that George W. Bush and other fortunate sons got into National Guard while working-class sons died in Vietnam. We can't ignore the basic unfairness of Wall Street executives paying themselves bonuses with our bailout money while millions of others can't find jobs. And it does not warm my heart to know that part of my school taxes are paying for Sandy Kress to send his kids to private school where they don’t have to take his tests that my kids do.

As is probably clear by now, I'm mad as hell, but I'm going to have to keep taking it. As long as Rick Perry appoints Kress to advisory boards and allows him to testify before the legislature as if he’s only representing a state board and the company making half a billion dollars, the game is probably too fixed to be fixed. I am Kress fallen that Sandy is making money off my children while protecting his own from the STAAR test, but it’s only offensive, not illegal. His transgression is a moral one, akin to selling sugary soda to kids while forbidding his own from rotting their teeth out. He has a classic conflict of interest between his kids and mine.

All this began with such good intentions, to end social promotion by not leaving any child behind in a failing school. But Kress has led us to hell by insisting that testing our children will make them smarter. Of course it doesn’t work that way any more than marking off their growth against a wall makes them taller. That’s why Kress sends his kids to a private school with our money while our kids forgo a real education so they can take his tests.

If Kress really believed that his tests made schools better, he’d send his own kids there. And if he knows better, he’d stop selling Texas tests that we can’t afford and that school districts increasingly don’t want.

— Jason Stanford
Behind Frenemy Lines blog





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.