Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Protests Sparked in Detroit Over the Dumping of Black History Books

Reader Comment:

Not surprised. Detroit is under state control, you think the state government cares about the city and the people that live there? *coughRacismcough*

I am so tired of lazy politicians. Emergency Manager Donald Weatherspoon is essentially a politician-cum-useless-appointee. If you've got 10,000 books/materials to take care of, you don't just throw up your hands and say "We don't have the money! Make those cuts! Efficiency is the Way! Everything is a business! Reduce overhead!". You use some effing imagination, and find a better solution.

There are thousands (possibly millions) of people throughout the US that would have responded to a call for help. For volunteers, donations, etc. There are entire departments of schools dedicated to historical preservation whose students need experience. What, you can't find an army of interns out of that? LAZINESS.

You couldn't have contacted the NAACP? Couldn't have found some black history experts with good connections? LAZINESS.

Hello? Kickstarter anyone? LAZINESS.

This is disgraceful laziness and a complete lack of imagination, empathy, and respect. If the EM cared, he would have made the effort to find a better solution. It's not that hard people. YOU HAVE THE INTERNETS. USE THEM.

The issue is, he didn't try. He didn't think. Donald Weatherspoon needs to go.

by Zach Schonfeld

A Detroit area school district has erupted in protest over the discarding of a historic book collection that is said to contain more than 10,000 black history volumes, included films, videos, and other artifacts. The blame, according to residents of Highland Park, a small city surrounded on nearly all sides by Detroit, belongs to Emergency Manager Donald Weatherspoon, who claims the collection was thrown out by mistake but that the district cannot afford to preserve it. Yesterday, angry residents held a public protest, blocking traffic, wielding megaphones, and displaying picket signs with slogans like "21st Century Hitler Burning Books" and "Dump The EM, Not The Books"—referring to the state-appointed emergency manager.

Among the picketers was Deblon Jackson, a Detroit-area musician.

"The emergency manager had been in the district for over a year and then they decided to throw away all the black artifacts—books that were no longer in print or published, all kinds of tapes and catalogues," Jackson explained to The Atlantic Wire. "We want to preserve those artifacts so our children have something to look back on. We're just mad about it and we're not going to stand for it, just throwing away our history like that."

The outcry began when a small portion of the volumes in question was discovered in a dumpster three weeks ago by Paul Lee, a local historian who helped assemble the collection. According to USA Today, the collection was largely the result of civil rights-era demands to incorporate African-American studies into school curriculums—especially in communities like Highland Park, whose population is about 93% African-American. Jackson hopes to place the books in a community center, but Weatherspoon has instead expressed interest in donating those with historical value to a library or museum. (Of course, the majority of the collection has already been lost to the dumpster.)

Marcia Cotton, a member of the Highland Park Renaissance Academy Board of Directors and lifelong resident, said she attended a meeting in which Weatherspoon took responsibility and claimed the books were discarded by mistake. Her fellow board member, Vice President Andre Davis, soon resigned over the controversy. But Cotton isn't so sure the books are the most pressing issue in the community.

"I would very much like to get above the fray of the controversy and rather discuss solutions to the looming debt crisis facing the school district, the decline in school enrollment and city population, and how best we can work with our city officials and provide a greater quality of life for our residents and quality education in a safe environment for our children," Cotton said in an email. "We can't solve 21st century problems with 20th century tactics."

Jackson, meanwhile, hopes to continue protesting.

"We have a protest scheduled every day this week until we get what we want," she said. "They don't want the children to read, in my opinion. How do you have a library with no books? How do you mistakenly throw books out?"

"This is a modern-day Hitler," she added.

Watch video footage of the protest here, via WXYZ-TV Detroit.

— Zach Schonfeld
Atlantic Wire





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.