Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

The Big Plot Twist That Doomed San Diego’s School Libraries

Ohanian Comment: Ugly reader comments on the site of this article reveal the plain and simple truth that San Diego taxpayers aren't willing to pay for libraries and the professional staff that is needed to staff them.

I live in a Vermont village of 3,000. We support a library in our schools and a town library (where I volunteer under the guidance of a professional librarian). Both in New York where I used to live and here in Vermont, my taxes are much higher than those of my relatives. School libraries were closed down in my California hometown nearly two decades ago.

By Christie Ritter

San Diego's school libraries will be open at least one day a week next school year. That's actually the good news.

Some schools' libraries have been closed for years. Even worse: Many of the libraries sitting empty are gleaming new facilities filled with comfy sofas, rows of computers and shelved full of books.

A few months ago, I asked my fifth-grader if he'd been to his school library lately. He said the last time he remembered going was in third grade. I spoke to his principal, Kimberly Lopez at Hawthorne Elementary School in Clairemont, and she said the school has not employed a library technician or assistant, much less a higher-paid librarian, for two years. If children want to check out books from the school library, the only staff member authorized to do it is a school clerk. But sheâs got other work to do, so her time in the library is limited.

Hawthorne is not the only school in this predicament. Across the district, 44 school libraries are unstaffed, and in some cases, have been dark for years. Many more are open only a few hours a week.

How did things get to this point?

When the economic crisis hit in 2008, the San Diego Unified School District had just finished building or remodeling 102 school libraries: 76 at elementary schools, 13 at middle schools, two for charter schools and 10 at high schools.

The building boom was funded by 1998's Proposition MM, a $1.51 billion bond that funded construction across the San Diego Unified School District. The libraries were built between 2001 and 2006, said Lee Dulgeroff, the district's executive director of facilities, planning and construction.

These sleek new libraries cost $79.6 million, according to materials obtained by VOSD through a public records request. But soon after some of the ribbon-cutting ceremonies, many libraries went dark. Contractual restrictions â on top of funding cuts and layoffs--contributed to the closings.

Why Parents Can't Fill the Gaps

In 2008, principals were forced to choose between librarians and health assistants, counselors and attendance clerks -- all considered crucial positions up till then.

"That was the beginning of school-based budgeting," said Chris Juarez, principal of Curie Elementary in University City. "We were given a blank slate and told 'You build it,' so we had to find our most basic priorities."

Juarez even ran a marathon in April 2008 and collected pledges to raise money to keep Curie's library staffed that fall.

But lots of other schools decided cutting library staff was the least-terrible option.

Faced with the prospect of their libraries closing, parents across San Diego volunteered to staff the libraries.

That was impossible, though, thanks to language in the school district's contract with the California School Employees Association, which represents library technicians and assistants. The rule says: "The district may accept the donation of work providing that it does not result in the layoff, reduction or replacement of bargaining unit employees or positions."

Schools have limited options when funding for a specific job is cut or if a library worker quits. The contract with library assistants prevents other school employees or volunteers from doing their job.

The same rule also prevented PTAs from going outside of the district's human resources department to staff their school library. Library workers have to come from a list of prequalified candidates from the district, and the hiring process can take months.

'It's Inequitable'

"To me clearly, the taxpayers have spoken, saying they wanted libraries," said Elaine Sabetti, a library tech at Lewis Middle School. "Parents are saying that they want them, but the district isn't finding it important. In no way is one day a week enough, to me it's inequitable, because you have other schools that are open full time."

Indeed, the impact across the district has been uneven. School leaders had some leeway in deciding what staff positions to fund and which to cut. Some schools never had to close their libraries at all; othersâ libraries have hardly been open.

Some schools had another option. Schools like Silver Gate, Sunset View and La Jolla Elementary kept their libraries staffed at least in part by using school foundation money to pay a district library worker. School foundations, or parent-fundraising groups, funnel millions of dollars into San Diego Unified schools each year, and the money can be used to bolster certain programs or to keep staff members around.

Donna Tripi, principal of La Jolla Elementary, said the decision to fund library staff is driven by the community. "When you have a foundation, it can support some of the needs you have, it's helpful. When you have Title 1 money, thatâs other discretionary money you can use for student achievement. It's the priorities of the site and what they feel like their goals are. We've always felt a library was very important."

Title I funds, which go to schools with a high percentage of low-income students, can also be used toward library staff.

Suzy Reid, mother of a first grader and a third grader at Ocean Beach Elementary -- where the library is open one day a week -- said fighting for library access has been a struggle. She called Ocean Beach Elementary an "in-betweener" school, because it doesnât have a foundation to support extras like a library worker, but it also isn't one of the poorest schools in the district, so it doesn't get much Title 1 federal funding either.

"The librarian is inundated and she has no time to spend with these children. We have meetings in the library, that's the most use it gets," Reid said. "We sit there surrounded by all those great books and technology, but nobody gets to use it."

Common Core

Many parents and educators think the need for functioning school libraries is greater than ever, thanks to the new Common Core standards being rolled out at schools across the country.

Barbara Flannery, a San Diego High School parent, said she's concerned that the move to the Common Core curriculum will only make the need for access to research materials greater, and exacerbate the gap between students who have Internet access at home and those who don't.

Barbara Baron, program manager of instructional resources and materials department for San Diego Unified, said the role of teacher librarian, who can assist students with research, will be even more important with the Common Core standards.

"Most of our students and many of our teachers know Google," Baron said. "I love Google, but to get that academic, really deep and rigorous information, it's not Google."

— Christie Ritter
Voice of San Diego





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.