Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Obama Backs Rewarding Districts That Police Failing Schools

Ohanian Comment:

"Our kids get only one chance at an education and we need to get it right."

"There's got to be a sense of accountability.

--President Obama told the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. See his full speech below

Right a pretense of accountability by firing all the teachers and ignoring the socio-economic disaster that capitalist greed has brought to this Rhode Island school and to so many others. Blame the teachers, not the bankers.

Below find two accounts of Obama's performance at the Chamber of Commerce event, where he presented the business solution to the problem of children not doing well in school: Admit no problems of capitalism. Admit no societal problems. Fire the teachers and principals.

It's unfortunate that journalists pose this as a disagreement with union officials. Across the nation, teachers, who do not feel represented by any fat cats in Washington D. C., be they corporate politicos or union officials, are enraged. Enraged.

If the union stood for teachers, they'd call for a mass walkout--from Alaska to Maine.

President Obama and Secretary Arne Duncan have become the standard-bearers for the Business Roundtable approach to education: It is an agenda of high stakes testing and privatization. When will the progressives admit that Obama is Bush on Steroids?

Not surprisingly, the Business Coalition for Student Achievement, coordinated by the Chamber and the Business Roundtable, an association of corporate leaders, applauded Obama's efforts.

"As we work towards reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, a focus on improving graduation rates and addressing the achievement gap will be critical to improving academic outcomes for our children," said Edward B. Rust Jr., chairman and CEO of State Farm, who co-chairs the business coalition. "Improving educational outcomes for students is an economic issue and a moral imperative we all must work on together."

If you want the lowdown on Edward Rust, CEO State Farm Insurance, co-chairs of the Business Coalition for Excellence in Education and on President Bush's transition team covering educational issues. On the board of McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., and with Harold McGraw is co-chair of the Business Roundtable, former chairman of The Business Roundtable's Education Initiative, a director of Achieve, Inc., a director of the National Center for Educational Accountability, and served on the National (Glenn) Commission on Mathematics and Science Teaching for the 21st Century, see Why Is Corporate America Bashing Our Public Schools?

Don't miss Mrs. Mimi's blog.

And don't miss Jim Horn's incisive comment America's Broken Promise Alliance, or No Chamber of Commerce Left Behind over at Schools Matter.

UNION NEWS: Let's never forget â or forgive â the day President Barack Obama officially declared himself a scab by slandering the teachers of Central Falls, Rhode Island... Obama's complete Chamber of Commerce Scab Speech

George N. Schmidt - March 03, 2010

It's time to inflate the rat and picket the White House and Chicago's public schools, now that Chicago has given the nation the biggest collection of scabs and union busters ever to work on the federal payroll. On March 1, 2010, President Barack Obama denigrated the teachers and staff of Central Falls High School in Rhode Island, endorsed the Big Lie of his education policy that test scores measure student and school "success" or failure independent of the grueling poverty that his friends have created, and that scabs ("replacement workers") and scabherders like U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan are the heroes of the day.

Following his March 1 speech to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce praising the decision of the Central Falls Rhode Island school board to fire all of the teachers at Central Falls High School, President Brack Obama became a scab. By supporting the Chicago Plan for corporate "school reform" during his years as a Chicago politician, Obama telegraphed that this is where his education policy would be before his November 2008 election.

Many people had hoped otherwise. By appointing Chicago's Arne Duncan as U.S. Secretary of Educatoin in January 2009, Obama demonstrated that the "Chicago plan" of union busting, massive racism and segregation, and privatization would become the national template. Anyone who had read Obama's two books (Dreams from my Father and The Audacity of Hope) and followed his actual career as a corporate stooge and Machine lapdog during his years in the Illinois General Assembly has no reason to be surprised this week.

So at some point as the President of the United States moves forward with his scabherding attacks on some of the most dedicated teachers in the USA, let's bring the rat out, even to the White House sidewalk, to let the world know what Chicago "hope" really means in the 21st Century.

And we should never forget that the slavish subservience of the current leadership of the Chicago Teachers Union, which joined Arne Duncan in policies that are now metasticizing across the USA under "Race To The Top", helped make the current national attack on the teachers and principals who serve the poor possible. By accepting the definition of test scores as a measure of school success and ignoring for years the context of brutal poverty that makes inner city teaching so challenging, Marilyn Stewart helped this scabbing get "traction" as they say. Only with "Fresh Start" and "TAP" firmly in place in Chicago could Barack Obama and Arne Duncan get away with what they are now doing.

Obama angers union officials with remarks in support of R.I. teacher firings

By Michael A. Fletcher and Nick Anderson
Washington Post

President Obama voiced support Monday for the mass firings of educators at a failing Rhode Island school, drawing an immediate rebuke from teachers union officials whose members have chafed at some of his education policies.

Speaking at an event intended to highlight his strategy for turning around struggling schools by offering an increase in federal funding for local districts that shake up their lowest-achieving campuses, Obama called the controversial firings justified.

"If a school continues to fail its students year after year after year, if it doesn't show signs of improvement, then there's got to be a sense of accountability," he said. "And that's what happened in Rhode Island last week at a chronically troubled school, when just 7 percent of 11th-graders passed state math tests -- 7 percent."

The board that oversees Central Falls High School took the startling step last week of firing 93 teachers and other staff members after the teachers union refused to agree to a plan for them to work a longer school day and provide after-school tutoring without much extra pay.

American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten, whose union represents the faculty in Central Falls, one of the poorest districts in Rhode Island, responded forcefully to Obama's remarks.

"We know it is tempting for people in Washington to score political points by scapegoating teachers, but it does nothing to give our students and teachers the tools they need to succeed," she said in a joint statement with other union officials.

In an interview, Weingarten said Obama's comments about the school "don't reflect the reality on the ground and completely ignore the commitment teachers have made to turn things around." Weingarten said the union was "profoundly disappointed by the comments" and said the president "seems to be focused on . . . incomplete information."

Obama has often challenged union orthodoxy in his education agenda, promoting the expansion of public charter schools -- which frequently are not unionized -- and teacher performance pay. The two major national educators unions are not formally opposed to those ideas, but many of their members are skeptical.

Education Secretary Arne Duncan has said repeatedly that he wants to work with unions rather than impose reforms on them, and the National Education Association, with 3.2 million members, and the AFT, with 1.4 million members, have generally sought to play down policy differences with the administration.

Obama's comments came as he spoke at a meeting of America's Promise Alliance, a group founded by former secretary of state Colin L. Powell and his wife, Alma. The group has launched an initiative aimed at curbing the nation's school dropout rate.

"This is a problem we cannot afford to accept and we cannot afford to ignore," Obama said during the event, at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce headquarters.

The White House said 1.2 million students drop out of school each year. The problem is concentrated in the nation's poorest schools and among minority students.

Obama has sought to combat the problem with an infusion of federal aid for school districts that develop innovative plans to help students graduate. With the proposed funding, Obama is placing a bet on four strategies to fix thousands of failing schools.

Each of the strategies, at minimum, appears to require replacing the school's principal. The "turnaround" model would also require replacing at least half the school staff.

"Restart" schools would be transferred to the control of independent charter networks or other school management organizations.
"Transformation" schools would be required to take steps to raise teacher effectiveness and increase learning time, among other measures. The fourth strategy would be closing a school and dispersing its students.

Obama Backs Rewarding Districts That Police Failing Schools

By Jeff Zeleny
New York Times

WASHINGTON-- President Obama said Monday that he favored federal rewards for local school districts that fire underperforming teachers and close failing schools, saying educators needed to be held accountable when they failed to fix chronically troubled classrooms and curb the student dropout rate.

The president outlined his proposal to offer $900 million in federal grants, which would be made available to states and school districts willing to take aggressive steps to turn around struggling institutions or close them.

The president's proposal, which was included in his 2011 budget request to Congress, is his latest criticism of America's failing public schools. In a speech at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Mr. Obama said federal aid would be available for the districts that are home to the 2,000 schools that produce more than half of the nation's dropouts.

He spoke alongside former Secretary of State Colin Powell and his wife, Alma, who lead America's Promise Alliance, an advocacy group dedicated to combating the school dropout rate.

"We know that the success of every American will be tied more closely than ever before to the level of education that they achieve," Mr. Obama said. "The jobs will go to the people with the knowledge and the skills to do them. It's that simple."

He singled out Central Falls High School in Rhode Island, where last week the school board voted to dismiss the entire faculty as part of a turnaround plan for the school, which has a 48 percent graduation rate.

At Central Falls High, he said, just 7 percent of 11th graders passed state math tests. Mr. Obama said he supported the school board's decision to dismiss the faculty and staff members. "Our kids get only one chance at an education and we need to get it right," he said.

The president's comments incensed the leadership of the American Federation of Teachers, which criticized Mr. Obama for "condoning the mass firing" of teachers at the Rhode Island school.

"We know it is tempting for people in Washington to score political points by scapegoating teachers, but it does nothing to give our students and teachers the tools they need to succeed," the president of the union, Randi Weingarten, said in a statement.

In their efforts to overhaul failing public schools, Mr. Obama and his education secretary, Arne Duncan, have frequently drawn the ire of teachers' unions.

In his speech on Monday, Mr. Obama said states would be asked to identify schools that perform at persistently low levels, with graduation rates of 60 percent or less.

To qualify for the federal money, known as School Turnaround Grants, he said, the school districts must agree to take at least one of the steps: firing the principal and at least half the staff of a troubled school; reopening it as a charter school; or closing the school altogether and transferring students to better schools in the district.

"If a school continues to fail its students year after year after year," Mr. Obama said, "if it doesn't show signs of improvement, then there's got to be a sense of accountability."

The $900 million grant program, which would be subject to Congressional approval, follows $3.5 billion included in last year's economic stimulus plan that also was aimed at improving school performance and lowering the dropout rate. The program would support interventions at 5,000 of the nation's lowest-performing schools over the next five years.

Mr. Obama is seeking to use federal money as an incentive for local schools to improve their standards. The initiatives his administration is pursuing are similar to those of the Bush administration. At the event on Monday, Mr. Obama recognized Margaret Spellings, a secretary of education under President George W. Bush, who was seated in the front row.

Mr. Obama said he was particularly troubled by the dropout rate. He said 1.2 million students left school each year before graduating from high school, at a cost to the nation of $319 billion annually in potential earning losses.

"Now it's true that not long ago you could drop out of high school and reasonably expect to find a blue-collar job that would pay the bills and help support your family," Mr. Obama said. "That's just not the case anymore."

The Powells, who founded America's Promise Alliance in 1997, announced on Monday a 10-year campaign called "Grad Nation" directed at the lowest performing high schools in the country and focusing on improving graduation rates and preparations for college.

"We've got to catch our kids long before they drop out," Mr. Powell said.

Remarks by the President at the America's Promise Alliance Education Event

U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Washington, D.C.

THE PRESIDENT: Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you very much. Thank you. Everybody please have a seat.

Let me begin by acknowledging some of the extraordinary people who are working on this extraordinary project. First of all, I want everybody to know, in case you haven�t already met him, somebody who is working tirelessly on behalf of the young people of America, my Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan. (Applause.)

I want to acknowledge Marguerite Kondracke, the CEO of America's Promise, who is going to be implementing so much of the terrific work that's been discussed today. Marguerite -- there she is, right there. (Applause.)

I want to thank Tom Donohue for your hospitality in this extraordinary venue; thank you very much and thanks for the Chamber's support for this terrific effort. I want to acknowledge Margaret Spellings, Arne's predecessor, who helped to lead a lot of the improvement that's been taking place and we're building on.

And obviously I want to thank the Powells -- and I will start with the more important Powell, Alma. (Laughter.) I want to say a word about the remarkable woman who introduced me, a champion of children, a dedicated public servant and the recipient of numerous awards. And Alma has poured herself into America's Promise Alliance, helping make it the largest partnership of its kind to improve education and help children in this country.

And perhaps that's not surprising, because being an educator seems to run in the family, as I understand. Even though one of her mother's parents was born into slavery and the other, just after abolition, both went to college, became teachers, four of their children followed them into the education profession. So her family has educated and enriched generations of Americans -- and our nation is better off because for it. And so we are very grateful to you for your extraordinary leadership. Thank you. (Applause.)

There's not much we can say about the man that Alma succeeds as chair of the Alliance that most people don't already know, anyway. I will say that I'm grateful for his friendship, for his counsel, and like so many Americans, I continue to be inspired by his leadership and by his life's story.

It's a story of a son of Jamaican garment workers, a student from the South Bronx, like me wasn't always at his best in high school, but who went to City College of New York thanks to the support of his family and his friends and his community. It's a story of a ROTC cadet who went on to distinguish himself first in Vietnam, then in the Pentagon, in the White House, and in the State Department; and who, after spending a lifetime fighting of behalf of America, has now taken up the fight for America's children.

So the leadership of Colin and Alma are -- that they are showing by spearheading the Grad Nation Campaign to end America's dropout crisis is just the latest chapter in their service to this nation. And so I want to publicly commend them and thank them for their extraordinary service. Thank you very much. (Applause.)

One last person I want to make mention of, because I think it bears on the extraordinary public-private partnership that's taking place here, we have the CEO of the Corporation for National Community Service, Patrick Corvington, who is here. Where's Patrick? There he is back there. (Applause.) And so we are hoping to -- we're hoping to make sure we get a whole bunch of volunteers engaged in this effort.

Now, it's fitting that we're talking about education here at the Chamber of Commerce. After all, for America to compete and to win in the 21st century, we know that we will need a highly educated workforce that is second to none. And we know that the success of every American will be tied more closely than ever before to the level of education that they achieve. The jobs will go to the people with the knowledge and the skills to do them -- it's that simple. In this kind of knowledge economy, giving up on your education and dropping out of school means not only giving up on your future, but it's also giving up on your family's future and giving up on your country's future.

And yet, that's what too many of America's children are doing today. Over 1 million students don't finish high school each year -- nearly one in three. Over half are African American and Latino. The graduation gap in some places between white students and classmates of color is 40 or 50 percent. And in cities like Detroit and Indianapolis and Baltimore, graduation rates hover around 30, 40 percent -- roughly half the national average.

Now, it's true that not long ago, you could drop out of high school and reasonably expect to find a blue-collar job that would pay the bills and help support your family. That's just not the case anymore. In recent years, a high school dropout has made, on average, about $10,000 less per year than a high school graduate. In fact, during this recession, a high school dropout has been more than three times as likely to be out of work as someone with at least a college degree.

Graduating from high school is an economic imperative. That might be the best reason to get a diploma, but it's not the only reason to get a high school diploma. As Alma mentioned, high school dropouts are more likely to be teen parents, more likely to commit crime, more likely to rely on public assistance, more likely to lead shattered lives. What's more, they cost our economy hundreds of billions of dollars over the course of a lifetime in lower wages and higher public expenses.

So this is a problem we cannot afford to accept and we cannot afford to ignore. The stakes are too high -- for our children, for our economy, and for our country. It's time for all of us to come together -- parents, students, principals and teachers, business leaders and elected officials from across the political spectrum -- to end America's dropout crisis.

This is a problem that I've actually been fighting for years. Way back when, when I was a community organizer in Chicago, I saw what happened to a family or to a school or to a community when a student dropped out. So I helped work with local churches in the region to -- and public school officials to get state funding for dropout prevention programs, and brought together African American and Latino leaders to help set up after-school programs -- because when we help keep kids off the street, when we give them a productive way to spend their time, then graduation rates go up.

So that's a commitment that I've carried with me to the Oval Office. And today, I want to announce steps my administration will take to help end the dropout crisis in the African American community, in the Latino community, and in the larger American community. Because we know that about 12 percent of America's schools produce 50 percent of America's dropouts, we�re going to focus on helping states and school districts turn around their 5,000 lowest-performing schools in the next five years, and Arne will be amplifying and providing details on how we can do this.

We'll not only challenge states to identify high schools with graduation rates below 60 percent, we're going to invest another $900 million in strategies to get those graduation rates up. Strategies like transforming schools from top to bottom by bringing in a new principal, and training teachers to use more effective techniques in the classroom. Strategies like closing a school for a time and reopening it under new management, or even shutting it down entirely and sending its students to a better school.

And strategies like replacing a school's principal and at least half of its staff. Now, replacing school staff should only be done as a last resort. The public servants who work in America's schools -- whether they're principals or teachers, or counselors or coaches -- work long and hard on behalf of our children and they deserve our gratitude. Keep in mind I've got a sister who's a teacher, my mother spent time teaching -- one of the most important jobs that we have in this country. We've got an obligation as a country to give them the support they need -- because when principals and teachers succeed, then our children succeed.

So if a school is struggling, we have to work with the principal and the teachers to find a solution. We've got to give them a chance to make meaningful improvements. But if a school continues to fail its students year after year after year, if it doesn't show signs of improvement, then there's got to be a sense of accountability.

And that's what happened in Rhode Island last week at a chronically troubled school, when just 7 percent of 11th graders passed state math tests -- 7 percent. When a school board wasn't able to deliver change by other means, they voted to lay off the faculty and the staff. As my Education Secretary, Arne Duncan, says, our kids get only one chance at an education, and we need to get it right.

Of course, getting it right requires more than just transforming our lowest performing schools. It requires giving students who are behind in school a chance to catch up and a path to a diploma. It requires focusing on students, from middle school through high school, who face factors at home, in the neighborhood, or in school that put them at risk of dropping out. And it requires replicating innovative ideas that make class feel engaging and relevant -- because most high school dropouts in a recent study said the reason they dropped out was that they weren't interested in class and they weren't motivated to do their work.

So that's why we'll build on the efforts of places like Communities in Schools that make sure kids who are at risk of dropping out have one-on-one support. That's why we'll follow the example of places like the Met Center in Rhode Island that give students that individual attention, while also preparing them through real-world, hands-on training the possibility of succeeding in a career.

And that's why we'll invest in accelerated instruction in reading and math to help students who've fallen behind make up credits and ultimately graduate on time. It's also why we'll foster better alternative high schools and transfer schools, where students who have dropped out and who are at risk of dropping out, can return to the classroom and earn their diploma.

That's how we can curb dropout rates and boost graduating rates. I have to point out, in the 21st century, high schools shouldn't just make sure students graduate -- they should make sure students graduate ready for college, ready for a career, and ready for life. And that's why we'll foster what are called early college high schools that allow students to earn a high school diploma and an associate's degree or college credit at the same time. We want to learn from successful charter schools where students can take advanced and college-level courses.

So government has a responsibility. Government can help educate students to succeed in college and a career. Government can help provide the resources to engage dropouts and those at risk of dropping out. And when necessary, government has to be critically involved in turning around lowest performing schools. And nobody has been more passionate about this than Arne Duncan.

But as I've said before, education is not and cannot be the task of government alone. It's going to take nonprofits and businesses doing their part through alliances like America's Promise. It will take parents getting involved in their children's education, consistently -- going to parent-teacher conferences, helping their children with their homework. I have to point out I just went to my daughter's parent-teachers' conference last week. She's doing very well, by the way. (Laughter.) It will take students, as well, showing up to school on time and paying attention to classes and staying out of trouble. They're not let off the hook. Education isn't a passive activity; it's an active one.

So educating America's sons and daughters is a task for all Americans. And that's what this alliance, that's what this effort is all about -- making sure that none of us think that it's somebody else's job, but rather we all accept our role to play in making sure that we have the best-educated citizenry in the world. That's what has made the 20th century the American century; that's what will make the 21st century the American century.

Now, there's an old story that Colin has told about a man named George Ellis, who lived about a hundred years ago. And George Ellis was a janitor. His job was to clean up after the artist Daniel Chester French. Some of you may have heard of French -- he's the one who carved the figure of Abraham Lincoln for the Lincoln Memorial.

So day after day, week after week, month after month, Ellis went about his job, barely uttering a word to Mr. French, other than say the occasional "hello" or "goodbye." And then one day, just when French had nearly completed his masterpiece, Ellis spoke up. He said, "Mr. French, I have a question for you." So the artist said, "What is it?" "Well, what I want to ask is how you knew all along that Mr. Lincoln was sitting inside that block of marble."

And as Colin pointed out, that wasn't a silly question. Because sometimes in this country and in our lives, we see blocks of marble and some people can see what's inside and some people can't. It was a question profound -- it was a profound question about how we recognize the potential within each of us, and chisel away at what's keeping it locked inside.

I'm absolutely confident that because of the work of Colin and Alma Powell, because of the work that Grad Nation campaign is going to be doing and America's Promise Alliance is going to be doing, because of the work that we're doing across this nation to give our children the best education the world has to offer, from cradle to classroom, from college through career, that we are chiseling away at the obstacles that lie in our path, that block our children's potential. We want to unlock that potential, carve it out so that our economy succeeds, so that this country succeeds, and so that our children and grandchildren succeed.

So thank you very much for the extraordinary work you're doing. Thank you all for your participation. May God bless you and may God bless the United States of America. (Applause.)

— Fletcher & Anderson and Jeff Zeleny and Pres. Obama
Washington Post & New York Times & Obama





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.