Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

TFA teacher gets angry response from Ackerman

Ohanian Comment: Maybe Philadelphia superintendent Arlene Ackerman has gone too far this time, comparing students to rocks. Teachers seem ready to resist the scripts Ackerman imposes.

Reader Comment:. I am so not surprised by Ackerman's response to people, in general. There is a strong disconnect between Ackerman, her administration, and teachers.

Reader Comment: When Ackerman is questioned or her commands are not followed, people tend to disappear.

Reader Comment: Reading from a script is not teaching. I am told what to teach, how to teach, and when to teach and cannot deviate from it. Then I get blamed when it doesn't work.

Reader Comment: And we NEED to stop it. We are the ones who see the damage we are creating. We have to revolt, people. Their lives are in our hands.

Reader Comment: First and foremost, she insulted each of our children when she said, "I can teach a rock to read." This mentality is exactly what has infiltrated the schools. Teachers are constantly struggling to convince those outside the classroom that our kids are better and more capable than the B.S. curricula, computer programs and elementary strategies we are told to use. The only results these things show are that our students can pass a test. What happened to real education? The district needs to close down for 8-10 months, restructure, and reopen. And I do believe kids would be better served outside of school for those 8-10 months than in the classrooms they are sitting now (not because of teachers though, because of the HORRENDOUS system). The system under serves and disrespects our students on a regular basis, and this is only further confirmed by Ackerman's comments.

NOTE: There are lots more teacher comments at the blog site. And they are worth reading.

by Celeste Lavin

When the young teacher attending a panel discussion about men of color and education stood up to tell Superintendent Arlene Ackerman that the School District's constant bureaucratic requirements impeded her ability to teach, she hardly expected what happened next.

Ackerman blew up at her and, in essence, told her to quit.

"What we need are teachers who don't make excuses," said Ackerman. "I don't want to hear about bureaucracy. We have always had bureaucracies. We are looking for people who say 'I can teach a rock to read.' If it is not the right place for you then you should find another place to go."

The audience of about 400 people was stunned.

The event, at the University of Pennsylvania, was hosted by Teach for America and the Makuu Black Cultural Center at Penn. The purpose of the forum was to discuss ways to improve the educational experience of men of color and entice more into the teaching profession. Notebook blogger Samuel Reed also attended the event and is working on wrote a post about the forum's topic.

Approached later, the teacher said she was a Teach for America corps member in one of Ackermanâs Promise Academies. Understandably, she did not want to give her name.

âDid you see that? Did you see her tell me to quit?â she asked a friend after the panel discussion broke up, still incredulous. Other teachers encircled her in support.

When she addressed Ackerman, she said that she and other teachers are under âpressure to increase numbers [test scores] in a way that isnât necessarily meaningful - in a way that isnât necessarily giving our kids better education.â She complained that teachers are âpressured to give make-up packetsâ of schoolwork so students can pass with Ds. But those Ds âdonât mean [the students] have [learned] those skills,â she said.

âHow are we supporting these teachers ⦠to give a student a meaningful education when we have these barriers that really shouldnât be barriers?â she said, citing the endless paperwork associated with referring students for the Comprehensive Student Assistance Program (CSAP) and filling out IEPs for special education students. She said that while these program are supposed to support students, teachers get little support in creating classroom environments that "give our students a really meaningful, powerful, impactful education that can lead to a real future and a real freedom.â

The audience, about a quarter of whom were young teachers themselves, offered the teacher the longest round of applause of the night.

Then things got tense. Moderator Omari Todd â the vice president for regional operations for Teach for America â told the teacher that heâd pass the question to the panel but did not want to âlose the spirit of what we were hoping to do tonight.â At that, an audience member in a City Year uniform jumped up to interrupt.

âExcuse me, how could you not lose the spirit when there are three young Black African Americans sitting right here in front of you - since you said you were taking questions, you never called on any one of us.â

After an exchange with the City Year participant and his companions about programs for Black male students and outreach programs for men of color to enter the field of education, Ackerman responded to the young female teacher, who appeared to be of Asian descent.

The superintendent started by recalling how, when she was in school, one of her teachers had a sign on her door saying: âIf my students do not learn the way I teach, then I will teach the way they learn.â

Then she told the teacher to stop making excuses.

The Notebook asked Ackerman's office if she wanted to comment further, but she did not reply.

We will update this post if we receive a response. Check back soon for Here's Reed's take on the topic of educating young men of color and bringing them into the teaching profession.

— Celeste Lavin
The Notebook blog





This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.