Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home



46 in the collection  

    Military-Academy Plan Draws Fire in Chicago

    Ohanian Comment: Surely it's just a coincidence that three-quarters of Nicholas Senn High School students are members of racial or ethnic minority groups, and that half are from families of recent immigrants.

    Catherine Gewertz

    Chicago school leaders' plan to open a military academy inside a public high school has run into resistance from community members angry enough to try to form a protective human ring around the school.

    Neighbors have been passing out fliers to spread the word about the proposed naval academy at Nicholas Senn High School. They packed a meeting last month in Senn's auditorium, booing and turning their backs as district leaders tried to present information about the academy. They organized "Hands Around Senn," clustering around the building on Oct. 28 in symbolic opposition to the proposal.

    Some opponents are upset because they believe the district didn't involve the mixed-income community of Edgewater, in the city's northern section, before formulating the plan. Others fear program cutbacks at Senn next school year, when the military academy opens in one wing. Some see the move as an unwelcome recruitment tactic during wartime.

    The academy is part of the city's Renaissance 2010 plan, which calls for opening more than 100 small, themed schools in Chicago to increase choice for families. That plan, which offers outside groups the opportunity to manage most of the new schools, has been intensely criticized as lacking community input. ("Chicago to 'Start Over' With 100 Small Schools," July 14, 2004.)

    Peter Cunningham, a spokesman for the district, said Senn High was chosen for the academy because the building, with 1,700 students and space for 2,800, is underutilized, and only 60 percent of the eligible teenagers in its attendance area choose to enroll.

    "We want to create another educational option that would make Senn attractive," he said.

    None of the programs at the school, including its prestigious International Baccalaureate program and its special courses for English-language learners from 70 countries, would be affected by adding the academy, he said.

    Wartime Concerns
    But skeptics doubt that assurance. Todd Pytel, the school's math department chairman, believes that district leaders do not understand the way the school uses space for such programs as its junior academy, a small-school setting for freshmen.

    "This is a proposal that would take resources away from kids who really need them, all for some political gain," he said.

    Social studies teacher Jesse Sharkey speaks at Nicholas Senn High School in Chicago on Thursday, Oct. 28. More than 1000 students, staff members, and community residents gathered to protest the district's plan to house a naval academy in the building.

    "They're just barging in taking the best side of our school," said Karina Matias, 16, a sophomore.

    Some resent introducing a military element into the school.

    "You cannot tell me that when we are in the middle of a war, that this doesn't play right into the military's plan to draft kids without a draft," said Laurie Hasbrook, a pacifist whose two young children attend a Roman Catholic school nearby.

    Some activists perceive racial undertones in the district's plan, noting that three-quarters of Senn's students are members of racial or ethnic minority groups, and that half are from families of recent immigrants.

    "It"s quite obvious that given its demographics, this plan can be construed as a direct assault upon a community of color," said Jamiko Rose, an organizer with Organization of the NorthEast, a community group in the area.

    Army Lt. Col. Rick W. Mills, the district's director of military schools and Junior Reserve Officer Training Corps programs, said Senn High would provide a military academy in a part of the city where no such option exists. Across Chicago, 11,000 students participate in JROTC programs, representing the four main branches of the U.S. military.

    The military academies are not recruiting tools, Col. Mills said. They focus on leadership, citizenship, character development, and community service.

    Col. Mills noted that of the 900 cadets who graduated from the city's military programs last spring, 71 percent went on to postsecondary education. Only 18 percent indicated they planned to pursue military service, he said, and of that group, only half sought active duty.

    Sheli Lulkin, the president of a 15,000-member association of condominium owners along the nearby lakefront, sees the military academy as a needed improvement for Senn.

    "A lot of people move out when their kids get bigger, because there is no good educational option," she said.

    — Catherine Gewertz
    Education Week


Pages: 3   
[1] 2 3 Next >>    Last >>

This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.