Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

NCLB Outrages

School size does matter in testing

Ohanian Comment: Of course these desperate educators must known that focusing on bubble kids will only work in the short term. But I suppose NCLB makes all education only short-term. Eat, drink, and be merry for tomorrow you die.

I rant and rant about "incentives," but I remember my own kidhood, how I periodically gave myself a sick day. I was an excellent student, even a perennial teacher's pet, but fairly regularly I wanted a day away from all this and so I played the sick card. As a diabetic, I found this pretty easy to pull off. [Maybe this was because every time I was home sick my dad bought me a stack of comic books.] I think the general principle of a day off every six days for perfect attendance is not a bad idea. Much better than whistles and tchotkas.

By Marlena Hartz

Superintendent Patricia Miller is new to the Fort Sumner school district. But when adequate yearly progress results from the New Mexico Public Education Department reached her desk Monday, and the district received a big AYP thumbs up, she was ecstatic.

“There was much hand-clapping and a dance of joy,” Miller said.

Somewhat muddling the district’s feat, however, are nationwide trends that show the federal mandated proficiency standards results often correspond to a district’s girth.

In the Fort Sumner School District, there are approximately 350 students.

It’s true, said Miller, “a small school is at a greater advantage because we know our students and their families very well and we can intervene in student issues.”
But larger school districts can learn to cultivate the winning methods of smaller districts, she said, by “developing personal relations with kids and developing individual improvement plans.”

By comparison, sevens schools in the much larger Clovis school district did not make AYP.

Texico Junior High School principal Rick Stanley points to student-centered philosophies as making a difference.

“We offer student incentives to come to school. Every six weeks students who have not missed a day of school get Friday off,” Stanley said. “One thing that would help a larger district is finding those students who are right on the bubble, just a few points away from being high (AYP) achieving, and trying to help them.”

That’s exactly what former La Casita Elementary Principal David Briseno did when the dual-language school didn’t meet AYP last year. He said school teachers gave borderline AYP students an “extra push” to edge them into the AYP proficient category, practicing a theory that although phrased somewhat differently aligns with Miller’s and Stanley’s.

For La Casita, the theory worked. This year, the school meet AYP.

La Casita also has the highest number of English Language Learners (136) in the Clovis district. In three other district schools significantly smaller ELL subgroups measured below par.

“We use a lot of different learning strategies with the ELL group,” said new La Casita Principal Mark Trujillo. “One of those is scaffold instruction. We break down vocabulary into smaller parts and make sure students understand the vocabulary before we move onto the next step.”

Yucca Junior High School also shattered AYP trends.

Although the school did not pass the 2005 AYP bar due to a low scoring ELL group, it did manage to pull its special education students out of a two-year trench.

Like Trujillo, Yucca Principal Alan Dropps credits inventive learning strategies for the turnaround, most specifically the newly implemented “Language!” program, also introduced in other junior high schools in the district.

The program, Dropps said, samples from a variety of tactical learning strategies, even employing a set of hand symbols to teach students.

Some students are visual learners; others students are oral learners; most notably, said Dropps, the program caters to each.

— Marlena Hartz
Clovis News & Journal


This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.