Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

NCLB Outrages

Officials Seek Flexibility on 'No Child' Law

Ohanian Comment: Kids don't need more test prep; kids need something exciting. I've written before about transforming a remedial reading room into a hands-on, messing around in science room. The results on standardized tests at the end of the year were impressive. This science room was unscheduled and untimed. Kids came when they could persuade their 'regular' teachers to let them out of class. All students were welcome (only their teachers and I knew that the low readers had to come). Over time, I noticed that really bright students and those with great difficulties came the most. One truly gifted second grader spent about half the day every day in the room.

A fifth grader showed up every afternoon. After a couple of weeks I pressed him for his teacher's name because I wanted to tell her what a conscientious student he was, often taking on the required "write up your experiment" task for the group he was working with. Only then did I learn he was in special education. His class was dismissed every day at 2:15. He would sneak back into the building and show up at my science room. It's a long story, but I used his work to convince authorities to get him out of special ed.

After hearing about the room from neighbors, one father, a truck driver, came every day with his shy first grader. The room's busy-ness intimidated her, but Dad really wanted her in there, so he came every day until she felt comfortable.

I think the key element in that classroom was students made choices about what they were going to study. I warned them that once they made a choice they had to stick with it for at least three experiments, so they took their choices very seriously. But the room was always crowded and busy, and students working on color chemistry always had an eye out for what was going on in bones or bridges or ice cubes or dinosaurs or the physics of sound. And so on.

These days, with directives from Washington D. C., not even teachers get choices.

By Maria Glod

Fairfax County school officials say the sanctions imposed under the federal No Child Left Behind Act aren't helping struggling students, and the system is seeking permission to try a different approach at one school -- McNair Elementary in Herndon.

McNair has not met the federal requirements for three years now, and under the law, students are given the right to transfer to a higher achieving school. But Fairfax is proposing that students be required to remain at the school, where tutoring services would be expanded and teachers would offer a three-week "jump start" program in August to help children who lag behind. Transfers would be suspended for two years under the proposal but would resume the following year.

Fairfax County School Board member Stuart D. Gibson (Hunter Mill) and Superintendent Jack D. Dale have asked the U.S. Department of Education to approve the change. Gibson said the school system is spending tens of thousands of dollars to send to a nearby school the high-achieving students who opted to transfer out of McNair. He said that most struggling students are choosing to stay put and that the money would be better spent on help for those children.

"The key is to direct the resources to where they are needed the most," Gibson said. "This is about helping children succeed, not about labeling a school as a failure."

Fairfax wants to implement the strategy as a pilot program next year. Education Department spokesman Chad Colby said officials will consider the request. Colby also said federal education officials are moving toward allowing more flexibility in how the No Child sanctions are imposed.

The No Child law, which calls for annual math and reading tests for students in grades 3 through 8, requires that schools improve scores each year. Subgroups of students -- including ethnic minorities, disabled students and students learning English -- also must make progress for a school to make the grade.

Under the law, schools that don't meet the mark for two years must allow students to transfer to higher-performing schools. Schools that fail to make progress for three years must offer private tutoring to low-income children.

Robert Pianta, education professor at the University of Virginia, said Fairfax's plan makes sense for a school such as McNair, which has fallen just short of the federal benchmarks. Last year, for instance, the 840-student school would have met the standard if two additional Hispanic students had passed the English test.

"It sounds like there are a lot of kids who are learning in the school, and there's nothing that's structurally wrong in the school," Pianta said. "You want to retain the kids in the school for whom the school seems to be working well and boost the scores of kids who are on the fence."

Last year the Education Department allowed four Virginia school systems, including Alexandria, to offer tutoring before allowing students to transfer to other schools.

Fairfax's proposal is similar. But Fairfax officials want to offer tutoring to all students who fail the standardized tests, instead of only the low-income students who are automatically eligible under the law. The McNair pilot also would add the three-week summer session.

"I want to go after the kids who need the help," Dale said, adding that students who already have transferred will be allowed to stay at their new school. "You have to go child by child."

— Maria Glod
Washington Post


This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.