Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

NCLB Outrages

Is the American dream still possible for Buffalo's poor children?

Ohanian Comment: The Buffalo school district implements Reading First, the federal plan for poor children. Scripts. Scripts. Scripts. As though this were a solution to children living in extreme poverty.

Extreme poverty: $10,000 a year for a family of four.

It is long past time for educators to defy corporate-politicos, to reassert their professionalism. and do what is right for children.

They might start by demanding that corporate politicos get the lead out. According to Neighborhood Legal Services Inc In Buffalo, almost 65% of children have lead toxicity. This is a place for Buffalo teachers to start. Flood the media with the lead problem, demanding that officials pay attention to this instead of whining about primary graders DIBELS scores.

Cite Michael Martin's research.

When will the revolution start?

Is the American dream still possible for poor kids in Buffalo?

For today's children, a different kind of poverty

By Charity Vogel

Poverty in Buffalo used to be a story of possibility. Think about the people who built this city years ago: immigrants who arrived with nothing in their pockets. Many of them found decent jobs in a growing city, worked hard and carved out a little slice of the American Dream.

Thatâs not the way poverty in Buffalo works anymore. Today, the city is diminished, and opportunities are, too. The story of poverty in Buffalo has become one of hopelessness. And children have become its biggest victims.

New census figures, showing Buffalo to be one of the poorest major cities in the United States, put hard numbers to the situation: Poverty here is severe. Itâs pervasive. And itâs devastating.

Nearly one in three adults in the city is poor. Among children, the rate is nearly 43 percent.

Of the very smallest children in the city â those under 5 â fully half are now growing up poor.

And, 22 percent of Buffaloâs children are surviving in what is called âextreme povertyâ â a standard of living so low it is half of the federal poverty level. Or about $10,000 a year, for a family of four.

Over the next three days, The Buffalo News will take a closer look at child poverty in the city.

Today, these children worry about getting a meal or sneakers for school. Tomorrow, theyâll have a tough time finishing high school, getting a job, staying out of jail, owning a home. In other words: achieving the basic American Dream that built this city.

âItâs really hard to dream when the nightmare is your reality,â said Emma Jordan-Simpson, director of the Childrenâs Defense Fund of New York. âA lot of kids now â poverty is their nightmare.â

Ultimately, these kids will struggle to raise children of their own who will not be poor.

And that will shape the future of Buffalo for decades to come.

Their story, then, is our story.

No way out

Poverty, in 2007, is redefining what it means to have an American childhood. The American Dream â that golden ideal of hard work and success â has been pushed so far out of the picture for todayâs poor children that they donât even know it exists.

Some of them live in a world so desolate they have not a single person to look up to.

âMy dad doesnât answer my phone calls,â said Gabrielle Barrett, 10, a fifth-grader in South Buffalo. âI never see him. He lives somewhere by the Thruway.â

These kids donât know it, of course, but the Buffalo area has changed dramatically since their grandparents grew up. Jobs have disappeared, or moved out to the suburbs, taking much of the middle class â black and white â with it. The cityâs population is half what it was 50 years ago.

âYears ago, there was a sense of community â people could help. Today, people live lives of alienation,â said Jordan-Simpson. âThe traditional supports people would have had to raise their kids are gone.â

Because poverty is everywhere, and because it runs so deep, it has created a culture that -- especially for children -- is very hard to escape.

âThereâs a despair among young people now. They have no future â so they live for today,â said Judy Tutuska, who oversees food stamps for Erie County. âIâm a city person. I grew up in the city. And Iâve seen a world of change.â

Where poverty lives

Time was, most blocks in the city had a poor family or two. In those days, local and national poverty experts said, families used to turn inward to solve crises: to relatives, churches and ethnic communities.

Today, in some neighborhoods, poverty affects almost every house.

Drive down some streets and youâll see this kind of widespread poverty, signified in blighted storefronts, boarded-up homes, rustedout cars and tacked-up sheets fluttering at broken windows.

One city resident, living on a cashierâs income, said she feels overwhelmed by the signs of poverty she sees all around her. She defined prosperity this way: Gutters on houses. Because there arenât any, on the homes on her street.

You can see Buffaloâs poverty in other ways, too.

The number of food stamp households in Erie County in which the families are working poor or other nonwelfare recipients has skyrocketed 64 percent since 2000, to more than 40,000 households, county data shows.

Meanwhile, the family-based social fabric has frayed, in some neighborhoods to the point of disintegration.

In Erie County, among 4,550 families with children who get temporary assistance checks from the Social Services Department, county data shows that just 550 are headed by two parents.

Among the 621 homeless families who turned to Erie County for help between January and October of this year, only 25 had two parents.

And, at the T.J. Dulski Community Center on the East Side, dozens of children gather each night for a hot dinner because they have nowhere else to go.

âNobodyâs home for these kids,â said Linda Hansen, a director at the Lewis Street center. âThese kids move in, they move out, they stay with relatives; we do have two of them that are homelessâ¦â

She stopped, to wipe away a few tears of frustration. âIâm sorry â itâs just, that kind of social condition â you know it exists, but when you see it, itâs hard.â

Shanay Johnson, 17, said she sees that social dysfunction all around her.

A senior at Bennett High School, Johnson lives with her mom, whom she calls her biggest influence, along with her grandma. Her dad is in jail; she hasnât heard from him in ages.

âNone of my friends â none of them have fathers that live in the same household,â said Johnson. âI guess itâs accepted.â

âBut I think it matters,â she said. âI wish I had my dad.â

That dissolving family fabric has been replaced, for many poor residents, by an array of government services, charity centers and socialservice agencies.

Those outfits try to fill all the services needed, but itâs a daunting task.

The job problem

Poverty in Buffalo is a bigger issue today than it was even a decade or two ago, officials said, because of the scope and depth of the problems some poor families have.

Those who want to work have trouble finding jobs when employment opportunities are steadily shrinking. Many available jobs donât pay well, or they require degrees and training that the poor often donât have and canât afford. Then thereâs the problem of getting to and from work when, as in many poor households, thereâs no car.

Add to that: addictions to alcohol and drugs, domestic violence, child abuse, truancy, food and nutrition problems, chronic illness and homelessness â people in the trenches in the battle against poverty in Buffalo see all these issues every day.

âYou have a generation of young people out there whose parents might outlive them,â said Catherine Lewis-Smith, director of a West Side medical office, who sees poverty-related health problems like obesity, heart disease and diabetes in many of her patients. âThatâs frightening.â

Many days, those who deal with the cityâs poor cringe at the magnitude â and complexity â of the problem.

âKids now are worse off,â said Michael Weiner, commissioner of Erie Countyâs Social Services Department. âWhen you have pockets of deep poverty, like we do in certain neighborhoods in the city, youâre going to have problems with crime. Youâre going to have high unemployment. Youâre going to have more abuse of children. Youâre going to have all kinds of other problems.â

Still, even today, many people donât realize how different poverty is in 2007.

A poll of Erie County voters that Zogby International did for The Buffalo News in early October shows that most people â 69 percent â believe the American Dream is still within reach for poor kids in Buffalo.

Two steps behind

When a community, like Buffalo, starts to tilt dangerously into poverty levels that are extremely deep, what happens is a reordering of the cityâs economic future, experts said.

âWhat we have is an alternative game of Monopoly,â said Dr. Mark R. Rank, a nationally known poverty expert at Washington University in St. Louis. âIf you grow up in a household in poverty, you wind up not having the opportunities of kids growing up in middle-class households. These kids are at a disadvantage in the job market.

âWe like to think everything is fair â that everyone starts with equal opportunities. But given those prior advantages, who do you think is going to win or lose? Thatâs what we have now, in this country â which is supposed to be a land of opportunity.â

Because of that, young people like Shanay Johnson are in the minority.

She completed an internship at Lewis-Smithâs medical office on the West Side last summer and has since landed a job at Victoriaâs Secret. She feels like sheâs getting ahead, a little bit, against the odds â but she knows many of her friends arenât. âIf you want to get out of poverty, youâve got to work hard at it,â Johnson said.

Antanette Cotton, too, is trying to become one of the lucky ones. Sheâs an unusual case: Her mom and dad are married, and they both work â at lower-paying but steady jobs. Though they donât make much, they plan to buy a house someday in the city.

For them, thatâs the American Dream â and they are raising Antanette to want the same thing.

âKids who are born in the ghetto, they stay there,â said Antanette, 15, who dreams of opening her own hair shop someday. âYou have to want more for yourself.â

A new study by a panel of poverty experts this spring estimated the cost of children living in poverty in America to be $500 billion each year.

At Georgetown University, one of the authors of the research, Dr. Harry J. Holzer, said this factors in the costs that continue into adulthood.

âWith kids, you know they grow up in this environment that affects them,â said Holzer. âIt reduces their earnings later in life. Theyâre more likely to engage in crime. And theyâre more likely to have bad health. All of those things cost money.â

One at a time

The scope of child poverty can seem daunting and frightening.

Those who work with poor kids say that sometimes the best way to help kids is to try to touch them, one at a time, with care and attention. Thatâs what Linda Hansen thinks.

When she goes home at night, satisfied, after feeding 40 hungry kids, she realizes this one-on-one attention is the best gift she can give them.

âThere is some hope,â she said. âThere are still kids trying to finish their education. I like to have conversations with the kids where I ask them, âWhatâs your plan?â

âWhatâs really troubling to me is when they say, âI donât know.â â

— Charity Vogel
Buffalo News


This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.