Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

NCLB Outrages

There's No Doubt No Child Law Works

Ohanian Comment: Did you know that Secretary of Education Rod Paige has envoys? I'm always suspicious of op eds written by hired guns. This one isn't suspicious; it's beneath contempt. S. Anne Hancock earns her living by saying NCLB is a good thing. Most of us saying it is a very bad thing don't get money. We do, in fact, lose money because now we are "too controversial" to be hired for speaking engagements, to conduct workshops, and so on. We do this out of a passionate commitment to public education. Make no mistake: our public schools are under attack.

Hancock, the hired gun, says parents appreciate the law. I wish she could read the desperate mail I receive from parents whose families are in shambles because of this law.

I remind you of what Hancock said when, as an announced envoy for Bush and Paige in Birmingham, Alabama, she said, "My teacher taught me how to read with phonics and she whipped my little hand with a ruler when I got it wrong. We know phonics works. We know regular testing of students works.

Yes ma'am. Just whip their little hands. That will do it.

For a full report on Hancock's Birmingham appearance, see


I would note that I, too, am a former public school teacher and college professor. About the only things I administrate are a website and a tomato patch.

As a former public school teacher, college professor and administrator, I'd like to offer a suggestion to those who resist education reform: Do your homework first.

The No Child Left Behind Act is their latest target of complaint. To hear them say it, the law goes both too far and not far enough at the same time.

These critics are prisoners of the educational status quo, which has become unacceptable to parents and unfair to millions of our children.
As I travel throughout the Southeast, I see and hear another view.

No Child Left Behind is winning fans among moms and dads, teachers and principals. They realize it is spurring improvement in the long-forgotten corners of our public schools, while options and teachers real training, including teacher-to-teacher workshops and grants for highly qualified teachers. While education
bureaucrats repeat their talking points, the law is identifying children who need the most help and getting it to them, as we work to give all children a quality education.

Take Georgia, for example. The number of schools that met their testing goals grew from 64 percent to 78 percent this past school year. When a school, based on test scores, is labeled "in need of improvement," educators know they must bear down and focus resources and attention where the need is greatest. For too many years we have hidden economically disadvantaged and minority children behind the rest of the student population, allowing high average scores to hide the achievement

Now that achievement gap is closing, and closing fast. Independent studies and rising test scores all across the country are confirming it.

The law works because it refuses to accept poor performance from any student. It also has teeth, something that has been sorely lacking.
Parents in chronically underperforming schools we all know they're out there may transfer their children to a different school or take
advantage of free tutoring.

School districts have a responsibility to inform parents in a timely manner of these options. Unfortunately, there are some bureaucrats who don't want to lose their lock on students and would like to keep parents
in the dark. Instead, I urge them to become part of the solution.

Finally, to those who charge that No Child Left Behind has not been fully funded, I would ask you to recheck your work.

Several credible, independent studies have concluded that the No Child Left Behind Act is adequately funded. Meanwhile, federal education
spending for Georgia schools has risen to $3 billion a 54 percent increase from when President Bush took office.

Like Bush and Secretary of Education Rod Paige, I believe all children have the ability and the willingness to learn. We can teach every one of
them. I can't imagine anyone wanting to leave a single one behind.

S. Anne Hancock also serves as envoy for Education Secretary Rod Paige
in eight Southeastern states.

— S. Anne Hancock
Atlanta Journal-Constitution


This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.