Orwell Award Announcement SusanOhanian.Org Home

Behind student success, an LAUSD librarian

Susan Notes:

Three cheers to Hector Tobar for this follow-up paean to librarians.

People who think libraries are outmoded and obsolete just don't have a clue.. They are short-term utilitarian to the core, and they won't understand the argument when you make it.

Reader Comment: So Rosemarie holds two teaching credentials, probably Multiple Subjects and School Librarian, plus she is a Nationally Board Certified Teacher and the LAUSD attorneys are questioning whether she is qualified to teach? You've got to be kidding!

by Hector Tobar

Rosemarie Bernier, the librarian at Hamilton High School, sees hundreds of students every day. She knows them by their study habits, the questions they ask and the books they read.

Joelle and Johanna love to run their fingers through old books. We find them in the stacks, admiring the beautiful, old binding of a Jules Verne novel.

Another group of "regulars" gathers at a table. Nahum and Livingston leaf through sheets of sample calculus problems, while Antonio reads the final chapters of Toni Morrison's great novel "Song of Solomon."

Many of them know Bernier's job is in jeopardy. So they line up to tell me all the things she does for them. How she helps run an Advance Placement psychology class. How she's guided them through subjects as diverse as Tunisian history, World War II and stem-cell research.

"You're really lucky if you meet a good librarian because they teach you how to succeed," says Sarah Robinson, 16. "I know I'm going to remember Mrs. Bernier for the rest of my life."

Bernier, who has been on the job at Hamilton, in Palms, since 1997, is a credentialed teacher and a credentialed librarian. In March, she and 85 other Los Angeles Unified School District teacher-librarians got pink slips as part of the district's budget cutting.

To get them off the payroll, the district is arguing that librarians don't teach and thus don't qualify for the seniority protections given to teachers.

My visit to Bernier's domain made it clear to me how false and illogical this argument really is.

Bernier prepares students to think like scholars. She teaches them how and where information is collected so they can begin to sift through the vast stores of knowledge to be found outside the classroom.

"Their teachers tell them they have to look for information that isn't in their textbooks," Bernier told me as we sat in her office, surrounded by stacks of soon-to-be-shelved books. "So they come to me."

Sometimes Bernier points her students to one of the 30,000 books in the school's collection. More often, she directs them to the library's computer terminals. Back when she started, Bernier had a single computer. "It had a dial-up modem, and didn't work most of the time." Now she has 67.

"A lot of kids don't have any idea what the Internet is," she told me, by which she meant they don't know all the ways all those pages get on the Web and which ones they can trust.

Librarians are the original information aggregators. It's a job they've been doing since ancient times, from scrolls and parchment to virtual books and digital databases.

Part of Bernier's job is to teach "digital literacy." In fact, she helped write the state standards for digital literacy for high school students.

She's also past president of the California School Library Assn. and a National Board Certified teacher.

"She's a giant in our profession," said John Hamrick, librarian at Robert Fulton College Preparatory, a middle school in Van Nuys.

Even so, this month Bernier was one of dozens of librarians summoned to the basement of a downtown building to defend herself and her profession at a makeshift LAUSD courtroom. She was questioned by school-district attorneys who were attempting to prove that teacher-librarians are not teachers.

"To watch her up there being badgered, with the lawyers questioning whether she was really qualified, really made us all angry," said Hamrick, not long before he too was called to the stand for questioning.

Last week, when I described the inquisition to which the librarians were being subjected ΓΆ€” and said most of the district's middle-school and high-school libraries would probably be closed ΓΆ€” many readers were outraged.

But a minority questioned if we even needed school libraries in this day and age, when Wikipedia and Google appear to have all the answers.

"They'd have us learning the Dewey decimal system when everyone today has the world's libraries at their fingertips instantly," one reader wrote.

It's not so simple, says Bernier, who has seen all the many ways students can get tangled up when they go to the Internet without guidance.

They might print out a 97-page document, for instance, to retrieve the information contained in a single paragraph. Or sit at a keyboard with a website address provided by a teacher that's so long they can never type it correctly into a browser.

A surprisingly large number of students don't have home Internet access. Bernier gives them their first email addresses, has them sign the district's computer-use policy, and tells them: "You're in the club now. You can come and use it anytime you want."

Her message to them about the Internet is twofold: Just about any question can be answered on it, but the answer you find won't necessarily be true.

"They have no notion of what bias is," she told me. "They have to learn to think for themselves, to research, to synthesize from many sources of information."

Every day, Bernier passes on to her students the traditions upon which a scholarly life is based.

"The idea is to help them get the information they need to put their ideas in their own words," Bernier said. "They learn to stand on the shoulders of the great scientists, philosophers and mathematicians."

How much is that worth? It's priceless if you ask me. And the future cost of doing away with these outposts of civilization and thought is also beyond measure.


— Hector Tobar
Los Angeles Times



This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a democracy. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information click here. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.